[ It is very charming. It would be even without the help of whatever was in the food and drinks Reggie's been sampling tonight, but of course that helps; Reggie's distracted for a second, but then he blinks, raising his eyebrow. ]

... Bulldog. Who else have you met from-- [ Wait. ] Whoa. Wait, seriously? Then are we sure we haven't just been snatched by some cult another town over? Kind of a crazy coincidence.

[ He's mostly being facetious, but... still seems plausible, considering. ]