All we truly have to go on is why they say we are here. You don't suppose our kidnappers are going to be honest about why they've collected us?

[Not to mention how, which is the most pressing question to him at the moment, or possibly second to how to get away.]

Elves are fiction where I'm from. [Interesting, to say the least.]

I'm-- [It's on the tip of his tongue to lie about it. If he knew he was still on Earth, it would come easily enough. Here, he has already revealed himself to one out of necessity, and others have known because of Crowley. If he lies and is then caught in it, well, it's the thought of that embarrassment that has him coming clean.]

--not human. I simply look it. Soooo.... [Something ending in "ation."] Enjoy chewing, do we?