Albert feels the disbelief and he knows that it makes very little sense. He should be asking Arthur to leave. He should be trying to distance himself from this man.

But he doesn't want to. He has no reason to, whatever Arthur says, whatever he has done, that is not the man that Albert has seen. Is a good man capable of doing bad things? Yes, undoubtedly. Can a bad man do good? Clearly, yes. He himself is not innocent, not pure or without sin, and he has no ground to judge Arthur.

"No, it is not fine. But I don't think you did it for fun, I do not believe you capable of torturing your fellow man just because you could. I think you might even regret some of what you have done. But you are not that man to me. And here we are. Without Dutch van der Linde and his gang. Here is a chance to start anew."